In his bestseller, Four Arguments for the Elimination of Television, Jerry Mander argued that television is, by its very nature, a harmful technology. Trumpeter (). ISSN: In the Absence of the Sacred. Jerry Mander Elmwood Institute. Jerry Mander is the author of Four Arguments for the. Urging that we come to a fuller understanding of the perils of technology, Mander examines the sociopolitical ramifications of innovations, focusing on the.
|Published (Last):||6 October 2007|
|PDF File Size:||3.45 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||11.46 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
It is rhe ‘csf. Where is it all going? Instead of concentrating on TV, though, it would have focused on the new technological axe: Life at the End of Empire”.
Jerry Mander – Wikipedia
Since the dawn of the absencd era, he says, the only consistent opposition has come from sacrde native peoples. In the Absence of the Sacred takes this argument a step further by examining our relationship to technology as a whole. Mander’s insights help us gain confidence to declare liberation from the technological imperative.
He only pays attention to the “pure” Indian who survives by hunting or fishing the way that he did a hundred or a thousand years ago. If you are a seller for this product, would you like to suggest updates through seller support? The European group wanted to take over the land that the tribe was on.
Amazon Restaurants Food delivery from local restaurants. Add all three to Cart Add all three to List. Rooted in an alternative view of the planet, Indians, islanders, and peoples of the North have not only warned of the dangers of technology, they have also been its most direct victims. She was attending university at the time and, for my birthday, walked me into the university bookstore and said — pick something, anything.
Before presenting a counter-argument to Jerry Mander’s, it would be fair to give some credit to him for presenting some valuable information about American Indian history and society.
While most leftists are familiar with Engels’ respect for Iroquois government, far fewer are aware that people such as Benjamin Franklin held similar views. In the s, they discovered oil on Dene land and pretty soon all the usual culprits descended upon them: Nor did I get the impression that he was recommending that we should shun advances in medicine, science or technology.
Follow the Author
He says at the beginning that this was his original plan. Well, I wasn’t a rebel when I got into advertising. The system works well, however, in Iceland. And that maybe the way of life that’s winning, through force, isn’t the better way.
They had two sons, Kai and Yari. Instead of dealing with the consequences after that fact; try to anticipate the consequence before hand and weigh the benefits of a particular development or technology against its true costs. In the case of the Dene, the alternative was there to begin with, namely their traditional way of life. Showing of 41 reviews. That is exactly what the problem is!
How do they affect our interaction with and appreciation of nature? I wish these two critiques were more seamlessly integrated, and that the transition between the two parts of the book was smoother and better rationalized.
Their sole agenda was defending Indian rights, on or off the reservation. Technology, I suggest, is only instrumental in a positivist, mechanistic, materialist paradigm that desiccates the human spirit.
Curiously, success came to him during the Depression. Reading this section, you come to realize that these attacks on native populations are not sporadic.
It was by being in advertising and realizing what advertising does in the system. In other places, such as India, Iraq, Turkey, Mexico, Chile, the Pacific islands, New Zealand, and Australia, millions more native peoples live a kind of in-between existence, while they are under cultural, economic, or military siege. To see what your friends thought of absencf book, please sign up. A former ad man, Mander doesn’t so much generate new ideas as collect and repackage challenges to techno-capitalist hegemony in compelling and understandable ways.
U guess I need to add a new shelf This was written in but is still very relevant today. Like I said, he may address some of this later but to manderr things out there and not relatively quickly address the most obvious counter arguments seems disingenuous to me.
And his starting point is to say people are really good at predicting the future, so this system of gatekeeper analysis will work for new inventions. We know how awful it was and another long, boring account of the atrocities isn’t necessarily helpful. Unfortunately, Fenelon uses a lot of academic jargon but his research is fascinating.
This meant challenging the government, not pleading fo it to be kinder and gentler. It is this very difference in world views that has made the assault on Indian people inevitable.
Amazon Music Stream millions of songs. The preceding chapters seem to me like two distinct, unfinished books: It takes courage to read books like this, books that crash through our common assumptions about the world and allow us to see society jetry a critical perspective. In an interview with Nancho. The chapter titled “Lessons in Stone-Age Economics” refutes the claim that people living off the land through hunting and gathering were worse off than people living under capitalism.
Advertising and also public zbsence work.
My father’s career had followed the path familiar to so many New York immigrants. Aug 03, Simone rated it really liked it.